Man Told to Stop Flying Using Golden Airline Ticket Sues the Airline

Published on July 24, 2022
Steven Rothstein ended up getting something everyone dreams of: a golden airline ticket. What is it? Well, it sounds just like it is. The owner could travel anywhere they wanted in the world for free!

Overall, Steven enjoyed the perks of this super-rare ticket for many years. However, he was then part of a large scandal that hit him like a ton of bricks. What could have happened?

The airlines claimed he was fraudulent, taking immediate action that sparked a feud headed straight to court. Did he win his case? Was there something else at play? One betrayal resulted in a huge decision that still affects airline companies to this day.

AAirpass

Steven’s golden airline ticket wasn’t a one-in-a-million deal, but he was one of only 66 people to get one. It cost him $250,000, and the unlimited ticket was supposed to last a lifetime. He bought his AAirpass in 1987 from American Airlines.

AAirpass

AAirpass

Bring the Family

Two years later, Steven chose to upgrade the AAirpass for $150,000 more. That meant he didn’t have to fly alone, bringing a guest with him on each plane journey. This opened up many new possibilities for the man and his family.

ADVERTISEMENT
Bring the Family

Bring the Family

ADVERTISEMENT

Traveling the World

Steven used the ticket enough to get his money’s worth. His family flew all around the world and country, growing closer despite his constant need to travel. The kids knew their dad would always be back, even though he had something like a second family.

ADVERTISEMENT
Traveling the World

Traveling the World

ADVERTISEMENT

Always Make Friends

Steven became close friends with the airline employees because he spent so much time with them. However, he stayed in touch with the people he met while traveling. For example, he might see a single man drinking at the airport bar and offer him the benefits of his golden airline ticket.

ADVERTISEMENT
Always Make Friends

Always Make Friends

ADVERTISEMENT

Bringing Families Together

His generosity didn’t have any bounds. Once, he let priests fly to Italy for the Vatican, and he also gifted some miles to those who couldn’t travel to see family members. He was helping bring loved ones together and did it for years.

ADVERTISEMENT
Bringing Families Together

Bringing Families Together

ADVERTISEMENT

The Mistake

American Airlines hadn’t planned on this. Originally, the pass was something for companies to buy their top employees, at least according to Bob Crandall, the chief executive from ’85 to ’98. Soon, it was apparent that the public was smarter than the airline.

ADVERTISEMENT
The Mistake

The Mistake

ADVERTISEMENT

Count on Us

Steven was now a well-known member of the AA family, and it caught the attention of Robert Crandall. He once wrote a letter to the man saying that Steven could count on the brand to keep the company going and honor his AAirpass long into the future.

ADVERTISEMENT
Count on Us

Count on Us

ADVERTISEMENT

Hitting Some Turbulence

Steven didn’t realize how that promise could crumble in time. By the 2000s, parts of his life were falling apart, which had once been focused on exhilarating flights and fun vacations, but it didn’t have anything to do with his AAirpass (yet).

ADVERTISEMENT
Hitting Some Turbulence

Hitting Some Turbulence

ADVERTISEMENT

Not the Same

Steven had a son, Josh, who passed away at age 15. Naturally, that changed Steven forever, and even the American Airlines employees noticed. One person said that he wasn’t the same person as before. However, he still remained generous.

ADVERTISEMENT
Not the Same

Not the Same

ADVERTISEMENT

Nothing Unusual

Six years after his son’s death, Steven offered to fly his family friend to London using his AAirpass. It wasn’t unusual for him to do such a thing, and American Airlines had always allowed it in the past.

ADVERTISEMENT
Nothing Unusual

Nothing Unusual

ADVERTISEMENT

Permanently Grounded

What was unusual here was what happened when the friend and Steven walked onto the plane. He claimed that an airline employee handed him a letter that terminated his AAirpass. Without warning, Steven and his friend couldn’t board the flight!

ADVERTISEMENT
Permanently Grounded

Permanently Grounded

ADVERTISEMENT

Needing Answers

Steven was confused and shocked. At that point, he had no idea what he had done wrong. He was finally grounded for the first time in his adult life, and it had nothing to do with him. He could only think of one way to get answers.

ADVERTISEMENT
Needing Answers

Needing Answers

ADVERTISEMENT

Not about the Money

Steven decided to sue American Airlines for $7 million, and it wasn’t pretty. People only saw a privileged man crushed about his lack of luxury transportation. No one really knew how hard it was for Steven and that it had little to do with the money.

ADVERTISEMENT
Not about the Money

Not about the Money

ADVERTISEMENT

Betrayal

Overall, Steven felt betrayed, which is why he started the lawsuit. He claimed that if there had been a problem, American Airlines should have told him to change the way he used his AAirpass. Ultimately, that was the issue, but he had no idea!

ADVERTISEMENT
Betrayal

Betrayal

ADVERTISEMENT

Misuse of the Golden Ticket

American Airlines didn’t like how Steven had used the golden airline ticket for the last 20 years. Most airline employees, his whole family, and Steven didn’t feel like he mishandled the pass. However, the revenue department of the company did.

ADVERTISEMENT
Misuse of the Golden Ticket

Misuse of the Golden Ticket

ADVERTISEMENT

One Rule

Steven claims that American Airlines only gave him one rule when he purchased the AAirpass ticket: Don’t give it to anyone else. He never did, but the company believed otherwise, and a representative explained that in court in full detail.

ADVERTISEMENT
One Rule

One Rule

ADVERTISEMENT

The Accusations

American Airlines claimed that Steven used the AAirpass card fraudulently by booking seats using fake names and then filling them with his carry-on bags. The company also said he had booked flights that he didn’t intend to board.

ADVERTISEMENT
The Accusations

The Accusations

ADVERTISEMENT

No Idea

This was a shock to Steven, especially since he left everything to his friends at the company when he required a seat on the plane. He had never been told that he had done something wrong or incorrect.

ADVERTISEMENT
No Idea

No Idea

ADVERTISEMENT

The Question of Guilt

There were many theories on who was guilty here: American Airlines or Steven. One airport employee said that they didn’t believe Steven did anything intentionally to break the rules and wasn’t trying to do so. However, the betrayal could have been premeditated.

ADVERTISEMENT
The Question of Guilt

The Question of Guilt

ADVERTISEMENT

The Failure

The airport employee also said it took interpretation on American Airlines’ part to sue Steven. Most people knew that AAirpass was a large failure for the brand, and the company lost millions of dollars. However, it was one man against the entire corporation, so Steven had no chance.

ADVERTISEMENT
The Failure

The Failure

ADVERTISEMENT

He Lost

A judge chose to rule in American Airlines’ favor in 2011. Just a few months later, the airline went bankrupt. However, it was back in action by 2014, the case had been closed, and Steven was left to stand on the ground, but only for a while.

ADVERTISEMENT
He Lost

He Lost

ADVERTISEMENT

Mysterious Circumstances

Many people still theorize about the details of this case, even many years later. Why did the airline never issue warnings to Steven, as he was a dedicated member? Why was he never a problem until this company was close to bankruptcy?

ADVERTISEMENT
Mysterious Circumstances

Mysterious Circumstances

ADVERTISEMENT

Never Know for Sure

Steven doesn’t have unlimited access to the skies anymore, but he still travels. He’s lived in France, Chicago, New York, Australia, India, Hong Kong, and Berlin, and he doesn’t plan to settle down soon. Still, this traveler’s story is debated online to this day.

ADVERTISEMENT
Never Know for Sure

Never Know for Sure

ADVERTISEMENT

The Plot Thickens

The infamous golden ticket mess saw renewed interest because of another well-publicized scandal on another airline. Harriet Osborne is a makeup artist and mother of two. The 31-year-old wanted to have a stress-free flight and ended up fighting with officials because of her outfit.

ADVERTISEMENT
The Plot Thickens

The Plot Thickens

ADVERTISEMENT

A Needed Break

Harriet finally decided to take some time off from her busy life after months of her friends begging her to do so. She went with them on a short vacation to Costa del Sol, which is a seaside community in Spain.

ADVERTISEMENT
A Needed Break

A Needed Break

ADVERTISEMENT

Dream Destination

The friends were excited about their getaway, which promised sun and warmth that was so different from the gray and dreary weather they knew at home. Plus, Harriet wanted to do something for herself and away from her kids, who she loved dearly.

ADVERTISEMENT
Dream Destination

Dream Destination

ADVERTISEMENT

Girls on the Town

These Londoners made the most of their time, doing activities like shopping, swimming, and sightseeing. On the last day, Harriet and her friends decided to go on a shopping spree that did ultimate damage later.

ADVERTISEMENT
Girls on the Town

Girls on the Town

ADVERTISEMENT

Can’t Pass Up

The group of ladies strolled through the Spanish streets, looking at window displays of stores, and Harriet saw something she had to have. El Corte Ingles had a shirt that looked adorable, so the young mom went inside.

ADVERTISEMENT
Can't Pass Up

Can’t Pass Up

ADVERTISEMENT

Disappointing Realization

She walked to the clerk immediately upon entering and asked about the beautiful garment. It was sheer and a style that Harriet rarely chose for herself, but this blouse was perfect. However, she recoiled at the price!

ADVERTISEMENT
Disappointing Realization

Disappointing Realization

ADVERTISEMENT

Confidence Booster

Harriet admitted that the piece was gorgeous, but it was out of her price range to buy. Her friends begged her to try it on before she made a final decision. Once she saw herself in the mirror, she loved it and had to have it.

ADVERTISEMENT
Confidence Booster

Confidence Booster

ADVERTISEMENT

The Splurge

She could not remember wearing a shirt before that flattered her body style so well. In the spirit of the vacation (and her friends’ insistence), she decided to splurge on this expensive shirt, but she’d come to regret it later!

ADVERTISEMENT
The Splurge

The Splurge

ADVERTISEMENT

Buyer’s Remorse

It was finally time to go back to the hotel and pack for the return trip. While she filled her suitcase, Harriet was filled with remorse. She shouldn’t have bought that shirt because it was so expensive. Plus, it was often too cold in London!

ADVERTISEMENT
Buyer's Remorse

Buyer’s Remorse

ADVERTISEMENT

Ill-fated Decision

To put that worry aside, she decided that she could wear it on the return flight. She didn’t know when her next chance might be! Therefore, she arrived at the airport with her luggage, went through security, and moved to the gate.

ADVERTISEMENT
Ill-fated Decision

Ill-fated Decision

ADVERTISEMENT

Cold Shoulder

The stewardess stood at the doors to give people greetings while they stepped aboard. However, the woman raised her eyebrows and said nothing to the young mom. It was odd, but she shrugged it off and went to her seat.

ADVERTISEMENT
Cold Shoulder

Cold Shoulder

ADVERTISEMENT

Growing Nerves

She was settling into the flight but saw the flight attendants crowded together in the back, whispering. What made things worse was that Harriet felt that they were staring at her while they talked.

ADVERTISEMENT
Growing Nerves

Growing Nerves

ADVERTISEMENT

Put a Top On

The flight attendant looked straight at Harriet and told her that she had to put a top on or she wouldn’t be flying on that plane. She was blindsided by those comments and thought she had misheard. What could be the problem with her shirt?!

ADVERTISEMENT
Put a Top On

Put a Top On

ADVERTISEMENT

Confused and Dazed

Yes, the shirt was somewhat sheer and exposed her cleavage, but she had taped it down earlier to be extra modest. Before she realized what had happened, the stewardess tried to cover Harriet’s body with her hands! She was startled by this and couldn’t believe it.

ADVERTISEMENT
Confused and Dazed

Confused and Dazed

ADVERTISEMENT

Compromise

Though she didn’t want to, Harriet went to the restroom and put on another shirt, coming back to see the other passengers staring. She was humiliated and gave the stewardess a piece of her mind. That caused the flight attendant to tell her to get off the flight, causing Harriet to cry and stand up.

ADVERTISEMENT
Compromise

Compromise

ADVERTISEMENT

Sleepless in Spain

Harriet had splurged on the trip, so she couldn’t afford a hotel now and had to sleep on the floor of the terminal. The next day, she got on the flight without an issue but decided to have the last word.

ADVERTISEMENT
Sleepless in Spain

Sleepless in Spain

ADVERTISEMENT

Her Revenge

When they landed in London, Harriet called various news outlets to tell her story. In one day, the entire world was talking about it. It didn’t make the airline apologize, though. Instead, it implicated her for the issue!

ADVERTISEMENT
Her Revenge

Her Revenge

ADVERTISEMENT