Googly Eyes
The eyes are the window to the soul, but too many eyes are just plain creepy. One person actually found a drawer filled with googly eyes of all sizes in an antique set of drawers after they had bought it.
Leftovers In A Wall
Some bizarre things have been found in new houses, but when one person wanted to redo the plumbing in their home, they got a gross surprise. Someone had actually left a half eaten hotdog in one of the walls right there in the pipes.